Patsy’s Pizza

Reviews

• Katie M.

  star star star star star 17 June 2026

  When I was in high school, Patsy's was our go-to for pizza and wings. The pizza wasn't too thick but not especially thin and was always fresh and delicious. The wings don't stand out in my memory but I know we always ordered them so they must have been decent. In addition to the pizza and wings, my mom usually got an order of the eggplant parm. I didn't appreciate it at the time, but she swore it was one of the best eggplant parm dishes that she's ever had.
  
  Even though we always had good experiences with Patsy's, I've found more conveniently located places to satisfy my pizza (Twin Trees) and wings (Shifty's) cravings since moving farther away from the west side of Syracuse.
  
  I practically forgot about the place until recently when a coworker mentioned that she had just picked up a couple of slices from Patsy's for lunch. It never occurred to me that we work right around the corner. I stopped in the next day and was ready to order a slice of cheese when I read the specials - one of which was eggplant parm and zucchini casserole. Even though it sounded too heavy for lunch, I couldn't help but order this comforting classic with a twist of zucchini.
  
  This dish hit the spot! The layers of eggplant and zucchini were tender but not mushy and the sauce was fresh and bright. How can a sauce be bright? I don't know but there's really no other way to describe it. I was completely satisfied without feeling too full.
  
  To round out my experience, the service was very friendly and efficient. Everyone behind the counter seemed to have a smile and I didn't have to wait more than a couple of minutes for my meal (which came neatly boxed with a napkin, plastic ware, and a soft roll with butter).

• Brenda L.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 16 June 2026

  You can order delivery through EatSreet via Yelp or thru GrubHub. This was my 1st time ordering pizza delivery in New York. Do not confuse this place with the pizza chain "Patxis." I got a medium pizza (8 slices) with onion, peppers, sausage and onions. I thought that their pizza topping options were standard (nothing extra that was unique). Other topping options included pineapple, ham, pepperoni, extra cheese, anchovies, mushroom. Their menu is expansive and includes things like salads, sandwiches, paninis, calzones, pizzas, wings and cookies. They do not offer a smaller size pizza but you can buy pizza by the slice. They have two crust options that include "original" and "NY hand tossed." You can also choose two styles: "standard" or "garlic." I got the garlic style and NY hand tossed. I do not know how the crust would have been otherwise.
  
  The delivery: great, food came in under an hour and the pizza was hot! The delivery didn't come with anything other than the pizza (no parmesan, no crushed red pepper, no napkins, plates, etc.).
  
  The crust: crunchy on the outer edge but less so toward the middle. Overall the crust was nice and had a nice crunch/chew with little crunch bubbles at the bottom. The bottom of the box was super greasy and went through to the other side. When I bit into the end, it made that moist squish sound because of the moisture from grease.
  
  The toppings: I'm confused because only half my pizza had toppings. The other half was only cheese but I didn't request 1/2 a cheese pizza. Also, I requested mushroom and there were very few mushrooms on my pizza. I think the pieces were like specks here and there.
  
  The sauce: there was little to no tomato sauce. The topping was mostly cheese. The cheese solidified and slid off when I took a bite into the pizza.
  
  I'm disappointed that only half my pizza had toppings. i never order plain cheese pizza. The middle of the pizza was super greasy and soaked the entire crust all the way through.

• Jen S.

  star star star star star 14 June 2026

  Ordered from grub hub on yelp and it was super easy fast and the food was great! Yay! Pizza!

• Shannon A.

  star star star star star 26 May 2026

  Food is ALWAYS delicious even the items other than pizza. Best eggplant in town by far! Amazon Greek bowl special. Staff is always extremely accommodating and friendly. Very clean and bright eat in area. Great place!

• Reed B.

  star star star star_border star_border 23 May 2026

  Eh, the meatball sub and eggplant sub are better than gregs pizzeria, atleast they season theirs.. The pizza was nothing special. I probably won't order from them again unless I'm really lazy since they are just down the street.